Z-Wave Device ON but Output Does Not Switch

Modified on Fri, 3 Jul at 1:33 PM

Overview

In some cases, a Shelly Wave relay device may show ON in the gateway, but the connected load does not switch.


The most common symptoms are:

  • The gateway - controller shows the output as ON

  • There is no relay click

  • There is no voltage on the output terminal

  • The connected load does not turn on

  • Power, current, or voltage values do not change as expected

If the device receives Z-Wave commands but the relay does not click and the output has no voltage, the issue may be related to the output stage, relay, wiring, protection state, or configuration.

This guide explains how to check the device step by step.


Safety first

Before opening the wall box or touching the wiring, turn off the breaker.

Live voltage checks must only be done by a qualified person. If you are not fully comfortable measuring mains voltage, contact an electrician.

Shelly Wave relay devices may switch mains voltage. Incorrect handling can cause electric shock, device damage, or fire risk.


Output terminal naming

Different Shelly Wave devices may have one, two, or three outputs.

Depending on the device model, the output terminals may be marked as:

Device typeOutput terminals
Single-output deviceO or O1
Two-output deviceO1 and O2
Three-output deviceO1, O2, and O3


The same troubleshooting logic applies to each output.

For example:

  • For output 1, check O1

  • For output 2, check O2

  • For output 3, check O3

When checking voltage, always measure the selected output against N, if this is valid for the wiring type.


1. Confirm that it is not only a gateway state issue

First, check if the gateway is only showing a wrong state. In your Z-Wave gateway, switch the output ON and OFF several times.

Watch the following:

  • The gateway entity state

  • Logs or events

  • Power, voltage, and current readings reported by device if available

  • The physical relay click

  • The connected load

If the gateway state changes to ON, but there is no relay click and no output voltage, the device logic may receive the command but the relay or output stage may not activate.


If the device can be controlled by more than one source, test all sources.

Examples:

  • Gateway (Hub)

  • Z-Wave direct association

  • Automation

  • Local wall switch

If all control methods fail, the issue is less likely to be caused by an automation or gateway configuration.


2. Test local control

Do not test only through Z-Wave. Also test local control from the physical switch input, if accessible or available. For single-output devices, test the switch connected to SW or SW1.


For multi-output devices, test the related switch input:

InputRelated output
SW1O1
SW2O2
SW3O3

Recommended test:

  1. Turn off the breaker.

  2. Open the wall box safely.

  3. Check that the switch input is connected correctly.

  4. Restore power only when it is safe.

  5. Press the wall switch.

  6. Listen for the relay click.

  7. Measure if the related output becomes live.

How to understand the result

Test resultPossible meaning
No click from Z-Wave and no click from local controlPossible hardware fault, protection state, or device issue
Click from local control but not from Z-WavePossible gateway, association, or configuration issue
Click occurs but no output voltagePossible relay contact, terminal, wiring, or supply issue
Only one output fails on a multi-output devicePossible issue with that specific output channel or wiring
All outputs failPossible supply, protection, configuration, or device-level issue

3. Check LED and alarm state

Check the LED on the device and check the gateway for alarms.


Shelly Wave devices may report protection events such as:

  • Overcurrent

  • Overheat

  • Overvoltage

  • Overload

  • Protection triggered

If a protection state is active, the device may switch off the output and prevent normal operation. Check for red LED alarm blinking and check the notifications in the gateway or Z-Wave JS UI.


If a protection alarm is active:

  1. Turn off the breaker.

  2. Disconnect the load from the affected output.

  3. Secure the wires safely.

  4. Power the device again.

  5. Test the output without load or with a known small resistive load.

Do not continue using the device with a load that triggers protection.


4. Power-cycle the device

A power cycle can clear a temporary state.

Steps:

  1. Turn off the breaker.

  2. Wait at least 30 seconds.

  3. Turn the breaker back on.

  4. Or use the Parameter 117 to reboot the device.

  5. Test the output again.

After the power cycle, test control from:

  • Your gateway

  • Direct association, if used

  • Local switch input

If the relay starts working again after a power cycle, the issue may have been a temporary firmware or protection state. If it fails again when the load is connected, check the load and wiring.


5. Verify configuration parameters

Incorrect parameters can make the output behave in an unexpected way.

Check the parameters in your gateway - controller.


Important parameters for single-output devices

ParameterFunctionWhat to check
Parameter 23O/O1 contact type, NO/NCCheck if output logic is inverted
Parameter 19O1 Auto OFF timerCheck if output turns off immediately
Parameter 20O1 Auto ON timerCheck if output turns on unexpectedly
Parameter 1SW/SW1 switch typeCheck if local switch behavior is correct


Important parameters for two-output devices

ParameterFunctionWhat to check
Parameter 23O1 contact type, NO/NCCheck O1 relay logic
Parameter 24O2 contact type, NO/NCCheck O2 relay logic
Parameter 19O1 Auto OFF timerCheck O1 timer
Parameter 20O1 Auto ON timerCheck O1 timer
Parameter 21O2 Auto OFF timerCheck O2 timer
Parameter 22O2 Auto ON timerCheck O2 timer
Parameter 1SW1 switch typeCheck SW1 behavior
Parameter 2SW2 switch typeCheck SW2 behavior


Important parameters for three-output devices

ParameterFunctionWhat to check
Parameter 23O1 contact type, NO/NCCheck O1 relay logic
Parameter 24O2 contact type, NO/NCCheck O2 relay logic
Parameter 106O3 contact type, NO/NCCheck O3 relay logic
Parameter 19O1 Auto OFF timerCheck O1 timer
Parameter 20O1 Auto ON timerCheck O1 timer
Parameter 21O2 Auto OFF timerCheck O2 timer
Parameter 22O2 Auto ON timerCheck O2 timer
Parameter 29O3 Auto OFF timerCheck O3 timer
Parameter 30O3 Auto ON timerCheck O3 timer
Parameter 1SW1 switch typeCheck SW1 behavior
Parameter 2SW2 switch typeCheck SW2 behavior
Parameter 3SW3 switch typeCheck SW3 behavior


Contact type explanation

The output contact type defines if the relay works as normally open or normally closed.

For a standard normally open setup:

  • Output OFF = no voltage on output

  • Output ON = voltage on output

If the contact type was changed to normally closed, the logic may look inverted.


For the symptom where the gateway shows ON but the relay does not click, the contact type is important to check, but it is not the only possible cause.


6. Measure supply and output voltage

This step must only be done by a qualified person.

With proper mains safety:

  1. Confirm supply voltage between L and N at the device.

  2. Command the output OFF.

  3. Measure voltage between the selected output and N.

  4. Command the output ON.

  5. Measure voltage between the selected output and N again.


For a standard EU AC installation with normally open contact type, the expected result is:

StateExpected voltage
Output OFFApproximately 0 V between O/O1/O2/O3 and N
Output ONApproximately 230 V between O/O1/O2/O3 and N


For multi-output devices, repeat the test for each affected output:

  • O1 to N

  • O2 to N

  • O3 to N, if available

If L-N supply is present, the gateway shows ON, but the output stays at 0 V and there is no relay click, the relay or output driver may be faulty.


Also check the terminals with power off.

A loose wire on L, N, or the output terminal can cause a dead output.


7. Disconnect the load and retest

A faulty or unsuitable load can trigger protection or damage relay contacts.


With power off:

  1. Disconnect the load from the affected output.

  2. Cap and secure all wires safely.

  3. Power the device again.

  4. Command the output ON and OFF.

  5. Listen for the relay click.

Result explanation

ResultPossible meaning
Relay clicks without load but not with loadLoad may be faulty, shorted, or causing overcurrent/inrush
Relay still does not click without loadPossible device hardware failure or internal protection
Relay clicks but output voltage is still missingPossible relay contact or terminal issue


Loads that can create high inrush or electrical stress include:

  • Pumps

  • Valve actuators

  • Transformers

  • LED drivers

  • Fans

  • Refrigerators

  • Air conditioners

  • Other inductive or capacitive loads

For some inductive or capacitive loads, an RC snubber may be required.


8. Compare with a known working device

If you have another working Shelly Wave device of the same model, compare:

  • Firmware version

  • Z-Wave parameters

  • Device class

  • Entity behavior

  • LED behavior

  • Relay click

  • Output voltage

  • Power and current readings


For multi-output devices, compare each channel.

Example:

  • O1 on the affected device compared with O1 on the working device

  • O2 on the affected device compared with O2 on the working device

  • O3 on the affected device compared with O3 on the working device, if available


Do not swap modules or loads unless this can be done safely by a qualified person. If a known working module works on the same circuit and load, and the affected one does not, this points to a device fault.


9. Re-interview or re-include only after hardware checks

A Z-Wave re-interview or re-inclusion can help if the gateway missed device information. However, if the device receives commands and reports the ON state, but the relay does not click, re-inclusion should not be the first step.


Before factory reset, try:

  • Re-interview node (reconfigure)

  • Refresh values

  • Rebuild routes, if communication is unstable

  • Firmware update, if available

  • Remote reboot, if supported by the device or gateway

Z-Wave JS UI re-interview

  1. Open Z-Wave JS UI.

  2. Select the affected device.

  3. Open Advanced.

  4. Run Re-interview Node.

  5. Wait until the process is complete.

  6. Test the output again.


Fibaro HC

  1. On the Home - main dashboard on the affected device click on the gear icon
  2. Select the Device configuration tab
  3. Press the Reconfigure Device button
  4. Wait until the process is complete.

  5. Test the output again.


Factory reset

Use factory reset only as a later step.

Factory reset can remove:

  • Associations

  • Routing information

  • Gateway connection

  • Node ID

  • Energy counter values, if supported

After factory reset, the device must be included again.


10. Likely conclusion

The device is likely physically faulty if all of the following are true:

  • Z-Wave commands are received

  • Gateway or Hub state changes to ON

  • Local control also does not make the relay click

  • Supply voltage between L and N is present

  • Output stays without voltage

  • No active protection alarm explains the issue

  • Power cycle does not restore operation

  • The same load works with another known working device

In this case, the possible fault may be in:

  • Relay coil

  • Relay driver

  • Internal relay contact

  • Output switching path

  • Output measurement circuit

Stop using the device on that load and contact Shelly support or your seller for warranty handling.

The most important symptom is the missing relay click when the output is commanded ON.


Information to send to support

When contacting support, include:

  • Device model

  • Firmware version

  • Gateway model

  • Z-Wave controller type

  • Z-Wave JS UI version, if used

  • Wiring diagram or photo, if safe to provide

  • Load type and power

  • Which output is affected: O/O1, O2, or O3

  • Whether the relay clicks

  • Measured voltage between L and N

  • Measured voltage between output and N when ON

  • Alarm or notification messages

  • Parameter values for contact type and Auto OFF/Auto ON timers

  • Result of power cycle

  • Result of test without load

  • Result of re-interview, if performed


Summary

If a Shelly Wave relay device shows ON in the gateway but there is no relay click and no voltage on the output, first check safety, wiring, local control, alarms, parameters, and the load.


For devices with multiple outputs, test each output separately.


If the device receives commands but the affected output never clicks or provides voltage, and no wiring, load, or parameter issue is found, the device may have a hardware fault.